Does My Water Heater Need To Be Replaced?
We have an A.O. Smith water heater that was originally installed in June 1991. Last month, our water started running hot and cold fluctuations when we were running the hot water. About the same time, out electric bill spiked by over $100 for the month. This leads me to believe the elements may have gone bad or are going. With a unit that is that old, should I replace the water heater or have someone repair what I suspect to be bad element(s)?
Related posts:
- Replaced Upper Thermostat In Electric Water Heater, And Still Have No Hot Water?
- Do Both Elements In A Water Heater Heat At The Same Time?
- An Element On Our Hot Water Heater Is Not Working Properly. Can It Be Fixed?
- Replaced Heating Element In Electric Water Heater, Still No Hot Water?
- Can A Rental Water Heater Be Replaced?


November 24, 2009 @ 10:28 pm
The elements are pretty cheap and easy to install—you can take one to home-depot and match it up.Shut the power -drain the tank-and unscrew the top and bottom element with a big wrench..It helps to Wd-40 em up—depending on the mineral build-up you may have to persuade the element to pull out The is a simple do -it yourself repair for under $50 bucks—and if the tank isnt leaking is worth it even if it only gets you another year.
November 25, 2009 @ 3:57 am
A bad element shouldn’t increase the power bill unless a grounded element is making the water very hot.
Be aware that the cost increase may not be related to the hot water fluctuations. There have been a lot of power rate increases as a result of the previous high energy prices. I heard Texas almost doubled their rates.
Almost sounds like a leaking hot water pipe to me, not the tank.
November 25, 2009 @ 7:48 am
if you don’t how to repair it yourself the labor cost will be the problem. If it is just the elements they are cheap from the hardware store. $15. but could be the thrermostate. google ” how to trouble shoot water heater” If hire someone you will prob. end up with $200 bill ,more or less. So ???????? there you go. see if you can edtermine what is wrong yourself or get a new one at that age.
November 25, 2009 @ 10:41 am
you could replace the elements but check with your insurance company because by replacing your hot water tank you may save money on your home insurance…its a win win situation, new tank with no worries and cheaper insurance.
November 25, 2009 @ 1:06 pm
definitely replace it…the tank is near its life expectancy anyway..if its typical 50-52 gal tank,,expect to pay $500-$700 incuding installation..
November 25, 2009 @ 1:57 pm
Get a new one because they all eventually start to leak.
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL
Leave a comment